Justice Blind ICE Lost. Original Art by Jezzie.
In August, Governor Healey signed the PROTECT Act into law and called it the strongest in the country. The PROTECT Act bars most civil immigration arrests without a judicial warrant or court order at courthouses, public schools, child care centers, and health care facilities, and it limits how state and local police and agencies can cooperate with ICE, including banning new 287(g) agreements. It also lets the Attorney General sue over violations in protected locations, allows civil rights claims against government officials including ICE agents, and lets parents arrange guardianship for their children in advance in case they are detained or deported.
On November 3, the courthouse protections in the PROTECT Act took effect. Under the text of the law, federal agents cannot make a civil arrest at a courthouse or on its grounds unless they first show a judge a judicial warrant. They cannot make a civil arrest inside a courtroom at all. ICE violated the law on day one.
According to the state's own Trial Court, ICE made five courthouse arrests on November 3 alone, and 28 in the first two weeks the law was in effect. In Chelsea, an eyewitness told GBH that agents walked into a courtroom, waited for the hearing to end, and handcuffed a young man in the hallway without showing a warrant. In Lawrence, reporters found no record of a judicial warrant for a woman taken into custody after her hearing. Immigrant advocates, including the statewide immigrant rapid response network LUCE, say they know of at least 26 courthouse arrests where no judicial warrant was presented.
ICE says it is not bound by the law. Its statement to MassLive argued that the Supremacy Clause means state politicians do not control federal law enforcement. Here is what that clause actually does. Under the Articles of Confederation, federal laws had no force in the states unless each state passed its own law to carry them out. The founders fixed that with the Supremacy Clause in Article VI, which made the Constitution and valid federal laws the supreme law of the land. Opponents warned it would overpower the states and infringe on state sovereignty, and supporters said it would only cover the limited powers the Constitution gives the federal government.
Today the Supreme Court treats it as a tiebreaker. When a valid federal law truly conflicts with a state law, the federal law wins. But the clause does not create federal power on its own, and it does not give federal agents the authority to do whatever they want. The 10th Amendment adds a second rule: powers not given to the federal government belong to the states, and the Supreme Court has said Washington cannot force states to do its work.
The real question is whether federal law overrides a state's rules for its own courthouses. The courts have not settled this. A federal judge upheld a similar New York law in 2025, finding that federal immigration law did not override it. That ruling is under appeal, and critics argue that a state cannot directly regulate federal agents. No court has blocked the PROTECT Act, which means it is the law in Massachusetts today.
So who enforces it? The people who passed it. The state's own website says the Attorney General can sue when ICE arrests someone in a protected location, courthouses included. The Trial Court says it is reporting the arrests to her office. On November 5, the Governor's office said it was evaluating its options. On November 9, Lawyers for Civil Rights warned the Attorney General that the protections could become an empty promise without enforcement. The arrests have not stopped. On November 18, the Governor's office said it had referred reports of potential violations to the Attorney General for investigation, and the Attorney General's office said it is actively evaluating all of its legal options. That means two weeks after the Governor's office said it was evaluating its options, the state is still evaluating.
A law that is not enforced is a performance, and our neighbors are the ones paying for it. From January 2025 through February 2026, the Trial Court counted at least 726 ICE arrests in Massachusetts courthouses. Prosecutors and advocates say victims and witnesses are afraid to testify. Families are being separated in hallways meant to be a place of justice.
Here is what you can do about it:
Call Attorney General Andrea Campbell at 617-727-2200 and Governor Maura Healey at 617-725-4005. Offices are open weekdays during business hours. Tell them to enforce the PROTECT Act, to act on every courthouse violation, and to tell the public how they will do it. Then call again every day until we are given a transparent answer about how this law will be enforced.
If you witnessed an arrest, report it through the state's portal at mass.gov/fedmisconduct.
Massachusetts made a promise. We do not break our promises, and we will keep calling until they keep this one.
Enjoyed this article? Get updates on the movement, volunteer opportunities, and more by clicking below.